July 17, 2012
The Empty Cradles of Florence
City’s Jewish population continues to decline.
by Chardonnay Copeland
FLORENCE, Italy – The demographic numbers add up to trouble for this city’s proud, storied Jewish community.
The demographic shape of any healthy, growing population is a pyramid, said Sandro Servi, a professor and historian specializing in Jewish Italian history. The base and largest segment, in other words, should be the very young, graduating up to the top, representing that population’s most aged.
Unfortunately for the Jewish community of Florence, in the past 20 years the pyramid has been turned upside down; it’s become, in Servi’s analogy, an inverted pyramid.
Once a thriving community
In 2010 there were 28,400 Jewish residents in Italy, or less than one percent of the world’s population of Jews according to the Jewish Virtual Library, a website for the American-Israel Cooperative Enterprise. This small group makes up less than one-half percent of Italy’s population.
Of that roughly 28,000, only about 700 to 800 live in Florence, or approximately 3 percent of the country’s Jewish population and less than one-half percent of the city's population. Just prior to World War II, according to Giovanna Bossi Rosenfeld, who gives Jewish historical walking tours in Florence , there were 2,300 officially registered Jews in Florence.
While Florence’s (and Italy’s) Jewish population numbers are relatively stable, they represent an aging community, Servi said. In the last 20 years, for example, the numbers of younger Jews have fallen, despite growth in Florence’s overall population.
Complicating matters for the Jewish community here, mainstream Italian culture threatens to assimilate younger Jews and, therefore, overwhelm their distinctively Jewish identity, traditions and practices.
Italian Jews have always known they are a minority, and that to prevent outcry or conflict, many find it easier simply to be assimilated to the dominant Roman Catholic culture, Emanuele Viterbo, general secretary for the Jewish Florence Community Center, said. Few can achieve the proper balance in yielding to Italian culture while maintaining a Jewish identity that is separate or distinct from the mainstream.
A heart-wrenching dilemma
Both the Servi children remained where they studied, meeting and marrying Jewish spouses there. In essence, then, Servi’s son and daughter sacrificed a great deal of their Italian identity in order to thrive as Jewish citizens abroad.
“It is very hard [as a Jew] in Italy, and you have to make compromises as such a small community when dealing with modern life” in this country, Bossi Rosenfeld said. “It is easier for younger people to just assume a different identity,” an Italian identity.
Servi said she had to fight to preserve her Jewish identity, awash as it was and is in the mainstream Italian culture.
“If I had not explored my [Jewish] heritage, we would have lost something,” said Servi, who is an active member of the orthodox Jewish community in Florence. “You have to fight to keep your heritage.”
To save tradition
But Florence’s Jews haven’t given up by any means. Sarah Rubenstein, an expat member of the city’s reformed Jewish community, said she is making every effort to cultivate in her children their Jewish identity and participation in the Jewish community.
Her compromise was sacrificing some orthodox ways and traditions in order to better allow her children to navigate and negotiate their identities. Florence’s reformed congregation does not have service every Friday night, for example, nor does the family always keep kosher, even though Rubenstein said orthodox Jewish food practices are important. In addition, within the reformed Jewish community, men and women are allowed to sit together during services, unlike at the synagogue. Rubenstein said it would be interesting to see if the next generation sticks with these traditions as they get older.
Without a Jewish school, the pressure on Florence’s Jews to preserve and perpetuate their identity, traditions and way of life is that much greater. And the stakes are high. At just 700- to 800-strong, who will carry the Jews of Florence into the future?
“It would be very difficult for a small population like Florence to continue losing grandsons and granddaughters,” Sandro Servi said.
Chardonnay Copeland is a junior communications major from Shiloh, Ga. She is specializing in public relations.
The Jews of Florence articles:
86-year-old Fortunata Franchetti Treves looks back.
Florence’s Jews ‘fight’ to maintain distinct identity in a culture dominated by Catholicism.
How Jewish Italians remember their history, pass on tradition and preserve their identity.
City’s Jewish population continues to decline.
City’s small Jewish population not enough to sustain local merchants.
Visitors share experiences.
Minority status has made Jews convenient scapegoats.
The Jews of Florence video coverage:
A look into the struggles Italian Jews face in attempting to combine and reconcile their cultural and religious identities.
The Treves family story represents in microcosm Italy's conflicted political and religious history. Hear the story first-hand from Fortunata Franchetti of Florence.
Because there are so few Jewish Florentines, the city’s kosher businesses have to reach out to the many Jewish tourists who come to the city.
Few tourists realize that the popular Piazza delle Repubblica in Florence is the former location of a 16th-century Jewish ghetto, one of Europe’s largest. Florentine Jews say they wish there was more recognition in the piazza for the hardships once endured.
Several sites of Jewish historical significance are preserved in Florence, sites that attract many Jewish visitors each year.
The Jews of Florence photo slideshows:
Jewish tourists from near and far visit more than just Renaissance art. Jewish historical sites like the synagogue and Jewish businesses cater to Jewish tourism in Florence, Italy.
A photo narrative highlighting the unique aspects of one Jewish-Italian family.
Jews discuss how difficult it can be to maintain their heritage in Florence.